Is your home insurance cash settlement enough?
A cash settlement is a payout from your insurer to repair your home yourself. Once you accept it, getting the work done, and paying for anything the money doesn't cover, is up to you. Oxide Construct is a registered builder that repairs, reinstates and renovates homes. We give you an honest quote to do the repair properly, with every cost explained, so you know whether the offer is enough before you say yes.
of the home insurance claims in ASIC's 2026 review were paid out at least partly in cash.
ASIC, Aug 2026of single-quote offers after Cyclone Jasper used a repairer the insurer already works with.
ASIC, Aug 2026insurers in that review had a consistent rule to add extra to their own builder's quote for the risk you take on.
ASIC, Aug 2026complaints about home building insurance went to AFCA, the free complaints body, in the year to 30 June 2026. That's up 25%.
Insurance Business, Oct 2026Independent.
You engage Oxide Construct directly and pay us directly. We aren't tied to any insurer or contracted to one, so nobody on the insurer's side has any influence in our quote. You get an honest quote to do the repair properly, priced at fair local rates tailored specifically for your home.
Yours to use.
Take it to your insurer to ask for a review, use it in a complaint to AFCA, or give it to another builder to quote against. If Oxide Construct does the repair, the assessment fee comes off the building work.
Registered.
Oxide Construct is a registered, fully insured builder. Our team's insurance and repair work goes back to 2005, and every repair we do is built to comply.
Nobody prices it fairer than a local builder.
Your insurer's loss adjuster usually writes the list of repairs. The price then often comes from a builder on the insurer's panel, working at rates agreed with the insurer in return for a steady flow of work. That may not be a price you can get.
In one claim ASIC reviewed, the insurer's own builder said it had undercut its costs by 40% for the insurer. After a complaint, the offer went up 16.5%, plus a further 20%.
The real test is the one AFCA uses: could you actually hire someone for that amount? Oxide Construct answers it with a quote for what we would charge you to do the work, and we're the builder who does it at that price.
Rates agreed with the insurer in return for a steady flow of work.
In your builder's quote
- 01
What a builder charges you for one job
- 02
Call-out minimums and return visits
- 03
Running and supervising the job
- 04
Permits and a compliant finish
- 05
A builder's warranty on the work
- 06
The builder's margin
On top, from your insurer
- 07
Price rises before work starts
- 08
Damage found once walls are opened
- 09
Losing your insurer's guarantee
What we price for at your home.
Repairing the home you live in is different from building a new one. The damage is only part of the job. A proper price also allows for how your home is built, what it's finished with, and how trades get in and out.
Oxide Construct looks at all of it before we quote, so these costs are in the price from the start. They aren't variations or surprises halfway through. When a cost is later called unforeseen, it was often visible on day one to anyone who assessed your home properly.
Specialty finishes
Your home may have high-end finishes that few builders know how to repair: designer wallpapers, Venetian plaster, microcement, and timber veneer panelling on the walls. Each needs a specialist trade and the right method, and blending a repair into the existing finish so it doesn't show is skilled, slow work. A builder who hasn't repaired these before is unlikely to price them properly.
Older and heritage homes
If your home is older, it may have ornate cornices, lath and plaster, leadlight and walls that are no longer square. Where your facade is heritage-listed or covered by a heritage overlay, the repair may need a heritage permit and like-for-like materials. That has to be understood before anyone fixes a price.
Site access
An elevated block, a steep driveway, a narrow side passage or a rear unit means every sheet of plaster and bag of render goes in by hand.
Parking and loading
If you're on an inner-city street, every trade pays for permits or parking, every day they're on site. In the CBD and inner suburbs that adds up quickly.
Where your home is located
If your home is on the city fringe, in a regional town or on the coast, it's further from suppliers and trades. Travel time, delivery fees and fewer local trades to choose from all push the price up, and trades charge more to come further. Oxide Construct checks where your home is and prices the travel and freight in from the start.
Materials in, waste out
Extra handling, several small deliveries instead of one, and bagged waste carted out where a skip won't fit.
Protecting a lived-in home
Covering floors, furniture and the rooms you're still using, and working around your household.
- A scope lists the damage and says little about the rest of your home. That's why a price can be right for the repair and still fall short once the job starts. We assess your home as well as the damage, so our quote is priced to finish the job.
Get your quote before their offer.
You don't need an offer to call Oxide Construct. If you've only just lodged the claim, we can inspect the damage and price the repair now.
When your insurer's payout offer arrives, you'll already have an honest builder's quote to check it against.
Some policies cover professional fees, usually only as part of the repair itself. Ask your insurer in writing whether they'll pay for an independent assessment before you engage us, and keep the invoice either way.
Cash settlement vs repair in Victoria.
Accept a cash settlement and your insurer hands the repair, and the risk, over to you. You organise the work and you pay for it, and Victoria's building rules still apply.
| What changes | If your insurer does the repair | If you take the cash |
|---|---|---|
| Who does the work | The insurer's builder, at rates agreed with the insurer | A licensed builder you hire, at their normal rates |
| Running the job | The insurer's builder manages it | You do, or you pay a builder to. A fair offer is priced on a quote that includes a builder's margin |
| Damage found once work starts | The insurer can add it to the job | You pay, unless the settlement is reviewed |
| Price rises | The insurer's problem | Yours. Across Australia, house building prices rose 5.7% in the year to September 2026 |
| Guarantee on the work | Often a lifetime guarantee from the insurer | Only your builder's warranty |
| Permits and building rules | Handled for you | Your job. Work that doesn't comply can make the home hard to insure |
| Builder registration and contract | Arranged by the insurer and its builder | In Victoria, work over $10,000 needs a builder registered with the BPC and a written major domestic building contract |
| Home warranty insurance | Arranged by the insurer and its builder | From 1 July 2026, your builder must take out home warranty insurance for work over $20,000 on homes up to 3 storeys |
Why cash settlement offers fall short.
When a cash settlement won't pay for the repair, it's usually for one of these reasons.
Part of the job left off
Your cash offer is priced from the insurer's list of repairs, the scope of works. If a room, a wall or part of the job isn't on that list, there's no money for it. AFCA, the free complaints body, sees the scope as generally the most important factor in whether an offer is fair.
A price you can't get
The quote often comes from a builder on the insurer's panel, priced at rates agreed with the insurer for a steady flow of work. They may not do your job for that price. AFCA asks a simple question: could you actually hire someone for it?
No builder's margin
Any builder you hire adds a margin to cover running the business and standing behind the work. AFCA's 2026 guidance says a fair quote includes it. A figure without it isn't one a builder can sign up to.
No contingency
A contingency is extra money on top of the quote. It's yours, for the risk you take on: prices going up, more damage being found, and losing your insurer's guarantee. AFCA typically adds 5% to 25%, most often 10% to 20%. None of the five insurers ASIC reviewed added one consistently.
Small jobs cost more
A tradesperson coming to one house charges a minimum call-out, buys materials by the full bag or tin, and often has to come back: plaster one day, sand and paint another. Rates agreed for a steady flow of panel work can leave those costs out.
Prices keep rising
Building materials cost about 30% more than they did five years ago, and across Australia house building prices rose 5.7% in the year to September 2026. Once you accept cash, any rise between the offer and the work is yours to cover.
Wear and tear taken out
If the insurer decides some of the damage comes from age or poor maintenance, that part isn't covered, and the claim is more likely to be paid in cash. In the Cyclone Jasper claims ASIC reviewed, one in four were cash settled in full or part for that reason.
What a fair payout includes
The repair cost with a builder's margin, a contingency on top, and the questions to ask your insurer.
Read the guideThe easy option for insurers can be the expensive one for homeowners.
In plain terms, cash is the quick option for the insurer, and the cost of finishing the repair moves to you. ASIC reviewed claim files from IAG, Suncorp's AAI, QBE, Allianz and Sure, about 65% of the home insurance market, and found settlement amounts can rise significantly after a complaint (ASIC). One regional Victorian financial counselling service negotiated $3.3 million more on cash offers for 40 clients, an average of $83,182 each (insuranceNEWS, Aug 2024).
Alan KirklandCommissioner, Australian Securities and Investments CommissionIf you're weighing up a cash offer, have the repair priced first by a builder who would do it. Oxide Construct isn't a claims manager or a loss assessor. We're the builder that does the work, so we quote it the way we'd actually build it, and you can see whether the offer covers it before you sign.
Get a builder's quoteWhat to do if your cash settlement is too low.
You can ask questions, push back and have the offer reviewed. These steps come from Moneysmart, ASIC's consumer site.
Ask how they worked out the offer
Ask for the list of repairs and the quotes behind the offer. Your Cash Settlement Fact Sheet has to break the total down.
Send your own quote
You can give your insurer quotes you've got yourself, including one from Oxide Construct. RACV's insurer, for one, says it will review a quote that is itemised and prepared by a qualified trade (RACV). Ours are itemised line by line.
Ask them to repair it instead
If repair is also an option, you can turn down the cash and have your insurer manage the work.
Check your time limit
Some claims can be reviewed for up to 12 months after they're finalised. Ask your insurer in writing how long you have.
Call your bank first
If you have a mortgage, the payout may go to your lender.
Complain, then go to AFCA
Use your insurer's complaints process first. If that doesn't fix it, AFCA is independent and free.
What you get from Oxide Construct.
A paid assessment, separate from your insurer. It's yours to use however you like. See how we work with homeowners and our insurance repair work.
| What you get | In plain terms |
|---|---|
| A builder at your home | We inspect the damage in person, with a moisture meter and the right tools, not from photos or a virtual assessment. |
| Our own list of repairs | Every damaged area, checked against your insurer's list so nothing is left off. |
| A transparent quote | Every cost shown and explained, so you can see where the offer falls short and why. |
| Fair local rates | What a builder charges for your job in your area, including call-out minimums and return visits. |
| A compliant finish | Priced to meet the building code, because a repair paid for with cash still has to. |
| The cost of running the job | Supervision priced by the hour and the builder's margin shown on its own line. AFCA's 2026 guidance says a fair quote includes a builder's margin. |
From the offer to a fair quote.
Four steps. You decide what happens at the end.
Send it in confidence
Upload what you have: the payout offer if you've got one, the insurer's list of repairs and photos. We'll call and tell you straight whether a quote is worth it.
Site assessment
A builder from Oxide Construct inspects the damage. It's a paid assessment, and we confirm the fee before anything is booked.
Your quote, explained
We write our own list of repairs, compare it with the insurer's and price the work fairly for your home and its location, showing what each cost is for.
You decide
The report and quote are yours. If Oxide Construct does the repair, the assessment fee comes off the building work.
Cash settlement questions.
Is what I send confidential?
Yes. Only Oxide Construct's team sees your documents. We won't share them with anyone, including your insurer, without your OK.
What does it cost?
Our site assessment is a paid service. We'll tell you the fee once we've seen what you sent, before anything is booked. If Oxide Construct does the repair, the fee comes off the building work.
Do I need an offer before I contact you?
No. Call us as soon as the claim is lodged. With our quote in hand first, you can check the insurer's offer the day it arrives.
Can my insurer pay your fee?
Possibly, but don't count on it. Some policies cover professional fees, usually only as part of the repair. Ask your insurer in writing before you engage us. If Oxide Construct does the repair, the fee comes off the work either way.
Is the insurer's figure what the repair will cost me?
Not always. Insurers usually have agreed rates with the builders on their panel, so their figure may be what the job costs them, not what it will cost you.
Does my payout have to include a builder's margin?
It should. AFCA's 2026 guidance says a fair quote is itemised, is one you can use to hire a builder, and includes a builder's margin. If the figure behind your offer has no margin, ask your insurer why.
What is a contingency, and who gets it?
It's extra money on top of the repair quote, paid to you. It covers the risk you take on with cash: prices rising, more damage being found, and losing your insurer's guarantee. AFCA typically adds 5% to 25%, most often 10% to 20%. It isn't part of a builder's quote, so ask your insurer whether your offer includes one.
I asked for cash when my insurer offered to repair. Does that change things?
It can. If your insurer was ready to do the repair and you chose cash, its offer may be based on what the repair would cost the insurer, not what it will cost you. Ask your insurer how that affects your offer, and check whether repair is still an option before you decide.
Can I ask for a repair instead of a cash settlement?
If repair is also an option, you can turn down the cash and ask your insurer to manage the repair.
Can I get more after I've accepted?
Sometimes. Some claims can be reviewed for up to 12 months after they're finalised. Ask your insurer in writing what applies to yours.
Will you deal with my insurer for me?
No. Oxide Construct is a builder, not a claims manager or a loss assessor. We give you a builder's quote for the repair and can do the work, but we don't represent you with your insurer, and we don't give legal or financial advice. Be careful with services that offer to manage your claim. The Insurance Council says they often charge a fee or take a share of your settlement, which leaves less for the repair.
Where do you work?
Across Melbourne, roughly an hour from the CBD in every direction, and Geelong. See our service areas.
Who is Oxide Construct?
A registered builder based in South Melbourne that specialises in repair, reinstatement and renovation, and a member of the HIA and Master Builders. We're the builder that does the work. Insurance repair work is where our team built their careers, going back to 2005.
Before you sign.
Send the offer in confidence. Oxide Construct will give you a fair, honest quote to do the repair properly.
Sources.
- ASIC, Beyond the payout: ASIC warns home insurers to reduce cash settlement risks, 31 August 2026
- ASIC, 26-202MR ASIC warns insurers cash settlements should not short-change homeowners in need, 31 August 2026
- ASIC, Fix your oversight of independent experts and improve communication on cash settlements, 5 June 2025
- ASIC, REP 768 Navigating the storm: ASIC's review of home insurance claims, 16 August 2023
- ASIC Moneysmart, How home insurance cash settlements work
- House of Representatives Standing Committee on Economics, Flood failure to future fairness, October 2024
- Flood failure to future fairness, Chair's foreword, October 2024
- Treasury, explanatory statement on Royal Commission recommendation 4.8, 2019
- Australian Bureau of Statistics, Producer Price Indexes, Australia, September 2026
- AFCA, Approach to general insurance claims handling, 10 August 2026
- AFCA, Factsheet: home insurance claim delays
- AFCA, Making insurance claims handling a financial service, submission, January 2020
- Emma Curtis, AFCA Lead Ombudsman for Insurance, Understanding cash settlements for insurance, April 2025
- Insurance Council of Australia, Scope of works: what is a scope of works and how is it used
- Insurance Council of Australia, Insurance recovery and claims process
- Insurance Council of Australia, Understanding cash settlements FAQ, January 2026
- insuranceNEWS, Ombudsman urged to toughen scope of works stance, September 2025
- insuranceNEWS, Policyholder fails to force insurer to pay for claim manager (AFCA determination)
- Insurance Business, Insurers face legally binding Code obligations for first time, 22 October 2026
- Consumer Affairs Victoria, About builders, tradespeople and other building practitioners
- RACV Home Insurance (Insurance Manufacturers of Australia), Cash settlement brochure
- Building and Plumbing Commission, Find and check a practitioner
Reviewed 10 November 2026 by Oxide Construct, a registered builder. Sources checked 10 November 2026. This page is general information about Australian home insurance and isn't legal or financial advice. Oxide Construct provides builder's evidence of repair cost and doesn't act as your representative with your insurer.